Homes for Sale in Old Town Pinehurst NC

Frequently Asked Questions

How is the for sale real estate market for homes in Old Town NC?

In September of 2026, prices for Old Town neighborhood, North Carolina homes for sale were up 26.3% compared to the previous year. The median sale price was $745,000; On average, they sold within 184 days compared to 20 days on market the previous year. There were 3 homes for sale in September 2026, an increase from 1 during the same month in the previous year.

How many homes are for sale in Old Town NC?

There are 11 homes in Old Town neighborhood, North Carolina for sale. Last month, there were 3 listings, and 1 a year prior in September 2025. The newest listing for sale has 4+ bedrooms, 4+ bathrooms, 3,982 SQFT, and .62 acres for $960,000 at 15 Mccaskill Road W.

Are prices rising or falling for homes in Old Town NC?

Compared to the previous month, prices are falling for homes in Old Town neighborhood, North Carolina. The median sale closing price was $745,000 in September 2026, which is lower than a month previous at $1,450,000. The median sale closing price rose 26.3% compared to the $590,000 median sale closing price a year ago in September 2025.

What is the average price per square foot for homes in Old Town NC?

$431.79 is the average price per square foot for homes Old Town neighborhood, North Carolina. This is an increase compared to the $357.69 average price per square foot last month, September 2026, and an increase compared to the $382.62 average a year prior in September 2025. Currently, a 3,982 SQFT House at 15 Mccaskill Road W in Old Town neighborhood, North Carolina has the lowest price per square foot at $241.08, while a 3,393 SQFT House at 55 Palmetto Road in Old Town neighborhood, North Carolina has the highest at $676.39.

What is the median list price for homes for sale in Old Town NC?

$1,549,000 is the median list price for homes for sale in Old Town neighborhood, North Carolina. This is an increase compared to the $745,000 median sale closing price last month, September 2026, and an increase compared to the $590,000 median sale closing price a year prior in September 2025.

What is the average days on market for homes for sale in Old Town NC?

184 days on market is the September 2026 average for homes for sale in Old Town neighborhood, North Carolina. This represents an increase from the previous month's average of 68 days on market, and an increase from the same month the year prior of 20 days on market average. Most recently, a 4+ bedrooms, 4+ bathrooms, 2,964 SQFT, and .36 acres House at 12 Village Lane in Old Town neighborhood, North Carolina has been on the market for 40 days, while 30 Medlin Road in Old Town neighborhood, North Carolina with 4+ bedrooms, 4+ bathrooms, 2,841 SQFT, and .34 acres has been on the market for 637 days.